Friday, May 09, 2008

民主派要反競爭法

政府宣佈再次為「計劃營商法」(又稱競爭法)進行諮詢。孫柏文用咗幾日時間,研究份諮詢文件,所以今日先至同大家分享我嘅睇法。

相信大家作為《金手指》嘅fan屎,都知道今次係政府第二次進行諮詢。上次失敗嘅原因,係因為政府列出7項「營商思維」,諗咗可能會犯法。

惡法之下諗吓都有罪


大家可能會問:「乜嘢叫營商思維?同實際行動有乜嘢分別?」

好嘅法例,即係大家都能明白嘅法例,就會清楚講明乜嘢實際行動做得同唔做得。例如,話到明不能進行婚前性行為,就係好法例。

咁壞嘅法例呢?就係大律師講到似層層,不過就連佢哋都唔明嘅法例,好多時唔會講乜嘢實際行動唔做得,只會話乜都做得。但做嘅時候,諗嘅嘢就會令你犯法。

例如,立法禁止當女仔為性玩偶──即係做愛可以,不過做嘅時候就唔可以諗住o趙完鬆。你可能覺得以上法例係好法例,咁乜嘢先至算當個女仔為性玩偶?你同個女仔搞完之後,你冇打電話畀佢,佢用以上法例去報警,咁又啱唔啱?做愛合法,唔打電話畀人都係合法,不過做愛加唔打電話就可能犯法?重點就係「可能」。

如果你畀得起錢,請公民黨啲大律師,佢哋幫你證明,唔打電話唔係因為你當個女仔係性玩偶,咁就冇犯法。現在你知點解公民黨咁支持「計劃營商法」。

界線模糊易主觀判決

大家可能會繼續問:「諗吓都犯法?香港有咁多維護思想自由嘅人,唔怪之得上次失敗。不過今次同上次有乜嘢分別?」分別就係上次嘅方案不夠含糊,不能瞞天過海,所以今次嘅方案,政府特登將界定犯法嘅線,盡量模糊。到時政府將會非常主觀咁,決定進行調查。

所以,我在此希望所有民主派嘅人,反對呢條法例。試諗諗,全香港嘅中文報紙都賣6蚊。一旦由淫審處、消委會等官僚,控制進行調查嘅大關,只要有愛國組織投訴,話合謀定價,24小時之後,各大報館將會有政府調查員進駐,將高層啲電郵、文件全部攞走,你話到時新聞自由又如何?傳媒挑戰政府嘅勇氣會去咗邊?Oh yeah,有香港電台就毋須要擔心,right?

所以,民主派嘅人,千祈唔可以畀政府咁大嘅權力。現有方案,就係97年後,僅次於23條立法,政府膨脹權力嘅法例。冇民主政制嘅監察,實在權太大,太危險。

4 comments:

  1. I think 民主派 need a person with economic knowledge and mind. Have you ever considered to join?
    Bravo

    ReplyDelete
  2. If I did run, will you donate to help?

    ReplyDelete
  3. As seen from many recent actions, 民主派 starts to see they lack a core competitiveness i.e. just ideology is not sustainable. Their background preclude them from saying things from businessmen perspectives. If you can persuade them that economic perspective is what a HK average citizen wants - 1) economic thinking = rationality = system thinking, 2) can solve NOT only business problem, 3) NOT necessarily sided with the businessman per se, 4) HK average citizen want HK prosperous, which is founded on a good "business" environment - including a fair welfare, education, internet/telecom system...., then I think you can be a new pillar in 民主派.

    Donation? You will get it automatically.

    (P.S. 民主派 if only composed on lawyers can achieve a little as they just focus on the wordings)

    Bravo

    ReplyDelete
  4. 柏文兄:

    我們等咗香港保守黨呢樣嘢好耐,難得bravo兄英雄所見略同。

    ReplyDelete